Ten minutes of Chesterton
p. 26 Chesterton argues that theorists jump to hasty generalizations when they conclude things from reindeer drawings on caves. We should not construct sweeping statements from the drawings. Humorously, he points out that in the future, researchers could point to initials we've carved into walls or trees and conclude equally implausible reasons behind them (27).
He pokes fun of Well's assertion that religion evolved slowly out of these three old world realities:
1. Fear of chief of the tribe--Wells calls "the Old Man"
2. phenomena of dreams
3. cycle of harvest...death/rebirth
Chesterton concludes that they are too dissimilar, having no unifying theme: "Nor could anyone
imagine any connection between corn and dreams and an old chief with a
spear, unless there was already a common feeling to include them all"(27).
Then he moves on to say that Wells intentionally makes them remoter than they really are, "For the plain truth is that all this is a trick of making things seem distant and
dehumanised, merely by pretending not to understand things that we do
understand" (27).
The only possible conclusion is that these experiences, considered as
experiences, do not generate anything like a religious sense in any mind except
a mind like ours. We come back to the fact of a certain kind of mind that was
already alive and alone (29).
d. Man could already see in these things the riddles and hints and hopes
that he still sees in them. He could not only dream but dream about dreams. He
could not only see the dead but see the shadow of death; and was possessed
with that mysterious mystification that forever finds death incredible.
We come back once more to the simple truth; that at sometime too early
for these critics to trace, a transition had occurred to which bones and stones
cannot in their nature bear witness; and man became a living soul. 30
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Why This Blog?
Most of my mornings begin with Bible and coffee. This blog forces me to slow down, to nail down the text and be precise in my processing and...
-
We presume that whatever is unpleasant is our duty! Is that anything like the spirit of our Lord— “I delight to do Your will, O my God . . ....
-
Hello, "The rich and the poor meet together; the LORD is the Maker of them all." Proverbs 22:2 It's good to remember that ...
-
Geography of David 1. House of Saul --after the fight with the Philistines and the conquering of Goliath, Saul insisted that Davi...
No comments:
Post a Comment